What This Template Is

Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) is the provision litigants turn to when they reasonably believe their case cannot be fairly tried where it is pending. It empowers the High Court and the District Court to transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending before them — or before any court subordinate to them — to another competent court, to withdraw the case and try it themselves, or to retransfer it. In plain terms: it is the legal route for asking that your case be moved from one judge or court to another within the judicial system.

This template is for the most common scenario — a party to a civil suit (or appeal or execution proceeding) who wants the case shifted, usually from the court of one Civil Judge or Senior Civil Judge to another, or from one district to another. The grounds that Pakistani courts accept for transfer are well settled: a reasonable apprehension that justice will not be done (for example, the presiding officer has a personal interest in the dispute or a relationship with the opposite party); threats or intimidation making it unsafe for the applicant or his witnesses to attend the court; inordinate, unexplained delay amounting to a denial of justice; and the situation where two or more cases involving common questions of fact and law are pending in different courts and ought to be tried together. Transfers are also ordered where the presiding officer is unable to try the case for any reason, or where the balance of convenience genuinely requires it — for instance, where all parties and witnesses reside in another city.

What Section 24 is NOT: it is not a device for "judge shopping" — filing transfer applications because a judge seems strict or because an interim order went against you. Courts dismiss such applications, often with costs, and sometimes impose heavy costs where the application is found to be an attempt to obstruct proceedings. A transfer application must rest on concrete, verifiable material — not on a bald allegation of bias. This template structures your application the way the District Court and High Court expect to see it, with numbered paragraphs, a proper prayer, and an affidavit.

How to Fill in the Blanks and Where to File It

Fill in every bracketed blank precisely. The caption must identify the court you are applying to (the District Judge if both courts are in the same district; the High Court if the courts are in different districts), the case you want transferred (its number, title, and the court where it is pending), and the court you want it transferred to (or "any other competent court" if you prefer to leave the choice to the transferring authority).

Where to file: Section 24 gives the transfer power to two authorities. The District Judge can transfer cases between courts within his own district — for example, from one Civil Judge to another Civil Judge, or from a Senior Civil Judge to a Civil Judge, anywhere in that district. The High Court can transfer cases between districts. A frequent beginner's mistake is filing in the High Court for an intra-district transfer — the petition will simply be returned to you. File before the District Judge first; the High Court entertains the application directly only where the districts differ or where exceptional circumstances exist.

The affidavit is essential. Almost no transfer application succeeds on pleadings alone. Annex a sworn affidavit of the applicant (or an authorised attorney) deposing to the facts — the incidents of bias, the dates of threats, the history of delay — and attach every supporting document: certified copies of orders showing delay, copies of the FIR where threats were reported, the order-sheet entries, or the plaints of the two suits where you seek their joint trial. An application without an affidavit and annexures reads as an allegation; with them, it reads as evidence.

Procedure after filing: The court issues notice to the opposite party, hears both sides (Section 24 requires notice and hearing where the application is made by a party), and then passes an order. File the application with the fixed court fee applicable in your province (a miscellaneous application bears a modest fixed court fee, not ad valorem), keep a receipted copy, and note that filing a transfer application does not automatically stay the proceedings — ask for an interim stay of further proceedings in the subordinate court in the same application if the matter is urgent, and the transferring court may grant it.

The Complete Application Structure

``` IN THE COURT OF THE [DISTRICT JUDGE / HONOURABLE HIGH COURT], [CITY NAME]

Miscellaneous Application No. ________ of 20____

In the matter of: Civil Suit / Appeal / Execution Petition No. [BLANK] of 20[BLANK], titled [BLANK — NAME OF PLAINTIFF/APPELLANT] vs. [BLANK — NAME OF DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT], pending before the Court of [BLANK — DESIGNATION OF PRESIDING OFFICER], [CITY].

[BLANK — NAME OF APPLICANT], son/daughter/wife of [BLANK], resident of [BLANK — FULL ADDRESS], CNIC No. [BLANK] ....Applicant/Petitioner

VERSUS

1. [BLANK — NAME OF RESPONDENT NO. 1], son/daughter/wife of [BLANK], resident of [BLANK — FULL ADDRESS] 2. [BLANK — NAME OF RESPONDENT NO. 2, if any], [BLANK — ADDRESS] ....Respondents

APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 24 OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908 FOR TRANSFER OF THE AFORESAID CASE FROM THE COURT OF [BLANK] TO THE COURT OF [BLANK] / ANY OTHER COMPETENT COURT ```

Para-wise Pleading

Para 1 — The pending case. That the applicant is the [plaintiff/defendant/appellant — BLANK] in the above-captioned case, which is pending adjudication before the learned [BLANK — DESIGNATION], [CITY], and is presently at the stage of [BLANK — "recording of evidence" / "final arguments" / "awaiting judgment", etc.].

Para 2 — History and present position. That the case was instituted on [BLANK — DATE] and has been pending for [BLANK — DURATION]. That [BLANK — STATE THE MATERIAL FACTS SUPPORTING TRANSFER, for example: "despite the applicant's evidence having been recorded in __ 20__, the case has not been decided and no reason for the delay appears on the order sheet"; OR "on __ 20__ the learned presiding officer remarked in open court that __, which gives the applicant a genuine and reasonable apprehension that a fair trial cannot be had"; OR "on __ 20__ the applicant and his witnesses were threatened by persons accompanying respondent No. 1 inside the court premises, regarding which FIR No. __ dated __ was registered at Police Station __"; OR "another suit bearing No. __ titled __ involving the same property and common questions of law and fact is pending before the Court of __, and both cases ought to be tried together to avoid conflicting findings"].

Para 3 — Why the apprehension is reasonable, not fanciful. That the above facts are not a bare allegation but are supported by the annexed affidavit and documents (Annexures [BLANK]). That a litigant's reasonable apprehension of not getting justice — an apprehension that a reasonable person in the applicant's position would share — is a settled ground for transfer under Section 24, and the applicant is not questioning the integrity of the learned court generally but is seeking the protection of a fair trial.

Para 4 — Balance of convenience. That the transfer of the case to [BLANK — the proposed court] will not prejudice the respondents in any manner, whereas refusal will cause grave and irreparable prejudice to the applicant [and/or: "all the parties and the witnesses reside at __, whereas the case is pending at __, causing undue hardship and expense"].

Para 5 — No forum shopping / bona fides. That this application is being filed bona fide, in the interest of justice, and not to delay the disposal of the case. That no other application for transfer of the same case has been filed earlier by the applicant [OR: "an earlier application bearing No. __ was dismissed on __ for __, and the present application is based on subsequent events dated __, constituting fresh cause"].

Para 6 — No other pending proceedings. That no appeal, revision or other proceeding arising from the same situation is pending before any other court, and the applicant has not approached any other forum for the same relief.

Prayer

``` It is therefore most respectfully prayed that this Honourable Court may graciously be pleased to:

(a) Withdraw the above-captioned [Suit/Appeal/Execution Petition] No. [BLANK] of 20[BLANK], titled [BLANK] vs. [BLANK], from the Court of [BLANK — DESIGNATION], [CITY], and transfer the same to the Court of [BLANK — DESIGNATION], [CITY] / to any other competent court for trial and disposal in accordance with law; (b) In the meantime, stay further proceedings in the said case before the learned trial court till the disposal of this application; (c) Grant such other and further relief as this Honourable Court deems just and proper in the circumstances.

[BLANK — PLACE], [BLANK — DATE]

Applicant, through counsel: ____________________________ [BLANK — NAME OF ADVOCATE], Advocate High Court ```

Affidavit (to be filed with the application)

``` I, [BLANK — NAME OF DEPONENT], son/daughter/wife of [BLANK], resident of [BLANK — ADDRESS], do hereby solemnly affirm and declare as under:

1. That I am the applicant in the above application and am fully conversant with the facts of the case. 2. That the contents of paras 1 to 6 of the accompanying application are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. 3. That the documents annexed as Annexures __ to __ are true copies of the originals. 4. That nothing material has been concealed from this Honourable Court.

Verified at [BLANK — CITY] on this [BLANK] day of [BLANK — MONTH], 20[BLANK].

____________________________ DEPONENT ```

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Making a bald allegation of bias. Courts consistently hold that a mere assertion — "the judge is biased against me" — is not a ground for transfer; what matters is material from which a reasonable apprehension arises. Always anchor the allegation in something on the record: an order-sheet entry, a statement made in open court, a documented relationship, or a sequence of inexplicable orders. An application that says "I fear I will not get justice" without saying why is routinely dismissed with costs.

Filing in the wrong forum. Transfer between courts of the same district belongs to the District Judge; transfer between districts belongs to the High Court. Filing in the High Court for an intra-district transfer wastes months — the office will return the petition, and the delay counts against you if urgency is later questioned.

Using transfer as a delaying tactic. Filing a transfer application on the eve of judgment, or immediately after an adverse interim order, invites the finding that the application is mala fide. Courts in Pakistan have repeatedly imposed costs — sometimes heavy costs — on applicants whose transfer petitions were found to be attempts to avoid a strict judge or stall a decision. File promptly when the ground arises.

Forgetting the affidavit. An application without a sworn affidavit is, for practical purposes, an unsigned complaint. The affidavit converts your allegations into evidence. Equally, annexures must be legible, paginated, and referred to by number in the body of the application.

Not asking for interim stay. The subordinate court is not automatically restrained by the filing of your transfer application. If the case is at a critical stage, include the prayer for stay of further proceedings pending disposal of the transfer application — otherwise the trial court may proceed and even decide the case while your application is pending.

Filing a second application on the same grounds. Once a transfer application is dismissed on merits, a fresh application on identical grounds is barred by the principle of finality. If new facts arise afterwards, plead them as fresh cause explicitly; otherwise the second application will be dismissed as an abuse of process.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can the District Judge transfer my case to a court in another district?
No. The District Judge's power under Section 24 is confined to courts subordinate to him — that is, courts within his own district. A transfer from one district to another can only be ordered by the High Court. Filing in the wrong forum is the most common procedural error in transfer applications; identify where both courts sit before you decide where to apply.

Can the court transfer a case on its own, without any application?
Yes. Section 24 expressly permits the High Court or District Court to act "of its own motion" — without notice to the parties, though in practice notice is usually given. This happens, for example, when a judge reports that he cannot try a case for personal reasons, or when administrative considerations require redistribution of work among courts.

If my case is transferred, do the interim orders already passed still stand?
Yes. Transfer does not erase the record. All orders, pleadings, and evidence recorded before transfer travel with the case file, and the transferee court proceeds from the stage the case had reached. You do not start over — though the new court may recall witnesses where the law permits, the earlier proceedings remain valid.

My transfer application was dismissed. Can I file again?
Only on fresh cause. A dismissal on merits concludes the matter as far as the same grounds are concerned; a second application repeating them will be dismissed as an abuse of process, usually with costs. If genuinely new facts arise after the dismissal — fresh threats, a new incident of bias, a related case filed later — you may apply again, but you must plead and prove the new facts distinctly.

Is there any time limit for filing a transfer application?
Section 24 prescribes no limitation period — the application may be made "at any stage" of the proceedings. In practice, however, delay undermines credibility: an application filed years into the trial, or on the eve of judgment, will be viewed with suspicion unless the ground itself arose late. File as soon as the ground for transfer materialises.

Can I seek transfer of a criminal case under Section 24 CPC?
No. Section 24 of the CPC applies to civil suits, appeals and proceedings. Criminal cases are governed by the transfer provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which vest the transfer power in the High Court and the Sessions Judge. The grounds are similar — fair trial concerns — but the provision and procedure differ, so use the criminal provision, not this template.

The Bottom Line

Section 24 CPC exists to protect one of the oldest promises of the legal system: that a case will be decided by a court in which the parties can have confidence. It is a powerful remedy — a case can be moved across courts and even across districts — but its power is precisely why courts demand substance. Ground your application in verifiable facts, support it with an affidavit and documents, file it in the correct forum at the earliest opportunity, and resist the temptation to use it as a weapon against an unfavourable judge. Used honestly, it is the litigant's legitimate safeguard against the rare situations where the machinery of justice itself becomes the obstacle.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for your specific case.