Picture this: you are appointed as a judge of an Anti-Terrorism Court in Karachi on 19 September 2024. The law under which you are appointed gives you a fixed term of two and a half years — your appointment letter says so, and at the time there is no maximum age limit for the post. You take your oath, you start hearing some of the most sensitive criminal cases in the country, and you plan your life around a tenure that should run until March 2027. Then, a year into your term, the provincial assembly passes a new law setting a maximum age of 65 for ATC judges — and because you are about 70, the government removes you overnight, a full year and a half before your term was supposed to end.

That is what happened to three ATC judges in Karachi — Muhammad Yameen, Ubaidullah Khan and Syed Zakir Hussain. On 21 October 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) undid the removal. In a 15-page judgment authored by Justice K K Agha, a division bench led by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi set aside the Sindh High Court Circuit Court's (Hyderabad) order, declared the Sindh government's de-notification notification to be without lawful authority and of no legal effect, and reinstated the three judges.

This article explains, in plain language, what the FCC decided and why it matters far beyond three judges in Karachi. The ruling is about a principle every public servant, contract employee and fixed-term office-holder in Pakistan should understand: a new rule cannot cut short a tenure that was lawfully granted under the old rule — unless the new law says so, clearly and expressly.

What Happened on 21 October 2026

The Federal Constitutional Court reinstated three Anti-Terrorism Court judges who had been removed by the Sindh government. The key holdings, as reported:

  • The three judges — Muhammad Yameen, Ubaidullah Khan and Syed Zakir Hussain — were removed by the Sindh government under the age-65 rule introduced by the 2025 provincial amendment.
  • A division bench of the FCC, led by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, with the 15-page judgment authored by Justice K K Agha, held that the removal was unlawful.
  • The court set aside the order of the Sindh High Court Circuit Court's division bench at Hyderabad, which had earlier gone against the judges.
  • It declared the provincial government's de-notification notification without lawful authority and of no legal effect — in plain terms, the notification that ended their service was void, as if it had never been issued.

The decision was reported by ARY News on 21 October 2026 and corroborated by 99news.com.pk and The Express Tribune. As with any very recent judgment, the full text is not yet available in the law reports, so the finer points of the reasoning are drawn from press reporting — we flag where that matters.

How We Got Here: The 2025 Sindh Amendment

To understand the ruling, you need the backstory. Until 2025, Anti-Terrorism Courts in Sindh were set up under the federal Anti-Terrorism Act 1997, and the federal government held the key powers over them. On 8 August 2025, the Sindh Assembly passed the Anti-Terrorism (Sindh Amendment) Act 2025, which the governor assented to on 20 August 2025, with immediate effect.

The amendment did two big things:

  1. Transferred control of Sindh's ATCs from the federal government to the provincial government. Powers that the ATA 1997 had vested in the federal government — including the power to establish ATCs and, significantly, the power to increase or reduce the number of ATCs, or abolish them, with the provincial government's approval — moved to Sindh.
  2. Introduced a maximum age of 65 for ATC judges. This was the new rule that had never existed before. Until that amendment, there was no age ceiling for appointment or continuation as an ATC judge in Sindh.

Acting under the new age limit, the Sindh government on 22 October 2025 removed the ATC judges who were over 65 — including the three judges at the centre of this case. Their terms were cut short by the stroke of a notification.

The Judges Who Were Removed

The lead petitioner's story, as reported by 99news.com.pk, illustrates the injustice the FCC saw. He is a retired district & sessions judge — a career judicial officer with decades of experience. He was appointed as a judge of ATC-IV Karachi on 19 September 2024 under Section 14(2) of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997. Under Section 14(3), his appointment carried a term of two and a half years — due to end in March 2027. He was about 70 years old at the time of his appointment — and crucially, no age limit existed then. Nobody broke any rule in appointing him; a 70-year-old retired sessions judge was perfectly eligible to be an ATC judge in September 2024.

Then came the 2025 amendment with its 65-year ceiling, and on 22 October 2025 he was removed — roughly halfway through a lawful term that the law itself had granted him. He challenged the removal, lost before the SHC Circuit Court's Hyderabad division bench, and then took the fight to the Federal Constitutional Court, which has now reinstated him and his two colleagues.

A note on precision: the exact appointment dates and term arithmetic above come from press reporting. The legal principle the FCC laid down does not depend on the exact day count — it depends on the fact that a specified tenure had been granted under the law as it stood, and a later amendment was used to cut it short.

The FCC's Reasoning: A Fixed Term Is a Fixed Term

The heart of the judgment is a distinction that sounds technical but is actually simple: the difference between a fixed-term appointment and an at-pleasure appointment.

  • An at-pleasure appointment is one where the office-holder serves only as long as the appointing authority wishes. A new government, a new policy, a new rule — any of these can end it, because no tenure was ever promised.
  • A fixed-term appointment is one where the law (or the appointment letter made under the law) specifies a tenure — two years, two and a half years, three years. That tenure is a legal commitment. The office-holder has a vested right to hold the office for that period.

A vested right is not a favour that can be withdrawn on a whim. It can be cut short only in ways the law allows — for example, through misconduct proceedings, or through a lawful condition of continuation or premature termination built into the appointment itself. What it cannot be cut short by is a later change in the rules that says nothing about existing appointees.

That was the FCC's answer to Sindh's argument. The 2025 amendment introduced the age-65 limit, but it did not clearly extend that limit to judges already appointed for specified terms, and it contained no provision requiring that reading. The court held that the amendment could not be read as silently cancelling tenures granted under the previous law. The lead petitioner had been appointed for two and a half years under the law as it stood in September 2024; he had a vested right to serve until March 2027, subject only to lawful conditions of continuation or premature termination — and a new age bar, introduced a year later without any transitional provision covering him, was not one of them.

Why a New Age Limit Cannot Cut Short an Old Appointment: The Rule Against Retrospectivity

The principle the FCC applied has a grand old name in law: the presumption against retrospective operation. In plain language, it means this: new laws are presumed to apply to the future, not to undo what was lawfully done in the past — unless the legislature says, in clear words, that the new law reaches backwards.

Why does this rule exist? Because certainty matters. People plan their lives — and judges plan their service — around the law as it stands. If every new rule could retroactively cancel rights already granted, nobody could rely on anything: appointments, contracts, licences and tenures would all be hostage to the next amendment. The law therefore demands that when a legislature wants to take away a vested right — a right that has already accrued under the old law — it must do so expressly. Silence is not enough. Implication is not enough. The words must be there.

Apply that here. In September 2024, the law granted a 2.5-year term with no age limit. A vested right to serve that term accrued. In August 2025, the legislature introduced an age limit but did not say — in any provision the FCC could find — that the limit would apply to judges already serving fixed terms. The presumption against retrospectivity therefore protects the existing appointees. The new age bar governs future appointments (and, where the statute provides, future continuations); it does not reach back to erase a tenure the old law had already conferred.

This is also why the FCC could declare the de-notification "without lawful authority and of no legal effect." The Sindh government acted as if the 2025 amendment automatically ended the judges' service. But an executive notification cannot do what the statute itself does not authorise. If the Act does not empower the government to cut short existing fixed terms on age grounds, a notification purporting to do exactly that is ultra vires — beyond legal power — and void.

Who Appoints ATC Judges — And Who Controls ATCs Now?

The case also throws light on a question many Pakistanis ask: who actually runs the Anti-Terrorism Courts? The answer has two layers — the courts themselves and the judges who staff them.

Appointment of judges. Under Section 14 of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997, ATC judges are appointed by the government after consultation with the Chief Justice of the concerned High Court — a safeguard meant to keep the judiciary's voice in who sits on these sensitive benches. The appointees are typically serving or retired judicial officers (district & sessions judges), appointed for specified terms — which is precisely what gave the three Karachi judges their vested tenure.

Control of the courts. This is what the 2025 Sindh amendment changed. Where the federal government previously held the key administrative powers over ATCs in Sindh, those powers — including establishing ATCs and deciding, with provincial government approval, to increase or reduce their number or abolish them — now sit with the province. The FCC's judgment does not undo that transfer of control. What it does is draw a line: provincial control over the system does not include the power to rewrite the tenure of judges already appointed under the old law, at least not without clear statutory language.

For ordinary citizens, the practical upshot is stability: the ATCs hearing terrorism cases in Karachi continue with the judges lawfully appointed to them, and the province's new administrative powers operate going forward, not backwards.

What This Means Beyond These Three Judges

The ruling's real importance is as a precedent for every fixed-term office-holder in Pakistan — a large and growing category:

  • Contract employees of government departments and public bodies, hired for specified periods.
  • Heads of regulatory bodies, commissions and tribunals, who serve fixed statutory terms.
  • Deputationists and project staff appointed for the life of a project.
  • Anyone whose appointment letter or governing statute specifies a tenure.

The message to all of them is the same: your tenure is a legal right, not a favour. A subsequent change in service rules — a new age limit, a new qualification, a new policy — cannot silently erase it. The government must either honour the term, end it through a lawful mechanism the law actually provides (such as misconduct proceedings), or legislate the change with express retrospective or transitional provisions — and even then, such provisions face constitutional scrutiny.

And the message to governments and legislatures is equally clear: if you want a new rule to affect existing appointees, say so in the statute, in plain words — and be prepared to defend that choice. Drafting a transitional provision is the legislature's job; the executive cannot supply the missing words later through a notification.

There is also a narrower, immediate consequence: any other ATC judge in Sindh removed on the same 22 October 2025 age-bar notifications now has a authoritative judgment to rely on. And provinces considering similar age caps for other judicial or quasi-judicial posts have been put on notice about how the courts will read them.

A Note on the Sources

As with any judgment delivered days ago, the full text of the FCC's 15-page decision is not yet available in the law reports, and no PLD or SCMR citation exists yet. The account above — including the bench composition, the holdings, the 2025 amendment's dates and effects, and the lead petitioner's appointment details and term arithmetic — is drawn from press reporting by ARY News (21 October 2026), 99news.com.pk and The Express Tribune, which corroborate one another on the essentials. Where a detail rests on press reporting rather than the judgment text itself, we have said so. Lawyers wishing to cite this ruling in proceedings should wait for the certified judgment or its law-report publication before relying on the precise reasoning.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Who were the three judges, and what exactly did the FCC order? A: Muhammad Yameen, Ubaidullah Khan and Syed Zakir Hussain — judges of Anti-Terrorism Courts in Karachi who were removed by the Sindh government in October 2025 for being over 65. On 21 October 2026, a division bench of the Federal Constitutional Court led by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, in a 15-page judgment authored by Justice K K Agha, set aside the Sindh High Court Circuit Court (Hyderabad) order against them, declared the government's de-notification notification without lawful authority and of no legal effect, and reinstated them.

Q: What was the Sindh government's legal basis for removing them? A: The Anti-Terrorism (Sindh Amendment) Act 2025 — passed by the Sindh Assembly on 8 August 2025 and assented to by the governor on 20 August 2025 — transferred federal powers over Sindh's ATCs to the province and introduced a maximum age of 65 for ATC judges. On 22 October 2025 the Sindh government used that new age limit to remove judges over 65. The FCC held that the amendment did not clearly extend the age limit to judges already serving fixed terms, so the removals had no lawful foundation.

Q: What is the difference between a fixed-term appointment and an at-pleasure appointment? A: A fixed-term appointment specifies a tenure — for example, two and a half years under Section 14(3) of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997. The appointee has a vested right to serve that full period, endable only through lawful mechanisms. An at-pleasure appointment carries no promised tenure; the office-holder serves only while the appointing authority wishes. The three judges held fixed-term appointments, which is why the FCC protected their tenure.

Q: Can a new law ever cancel an existing fixed-term appointment? A: Only if the legislature says so clearly. The law presumes new rules apply prospectively — the presumption against retrospectivity. To take away a vested right like an accrued tenure, the statute must contain express language (a retrospective or transitional provision) covering existing appointees. Here, the 2025 amendment contained no provision requiring the age-65 limit to apply to judges already appointed, so it could not cut their terms short. Even express provisions remain open to constitutional challenge.

Q: Does this judgment undo Sindh's control over its ATCs? A: No. The 2025 amendment's transfer of administrative powers — including the power to increase or reduce the number of ATCs or abolish them, with provincial government approval — was not struck down. The FCC's ruling is narrower: provincial control over the system does not include cutting short the lawful fixed terms of judges appointed before the amendment, without clear statutory authority. The new powers operate going forward.

Q: Who appoints ATC judges? A: Under Section 14 of the Anti-Terrorism Act 1997, ATC judges are appointed by the government after consultation with the Chief Justice of the concerned High Court. They are typically serving or retired district & sessions judges appointed for specified terms — the consultation requirement is a safeguard for judicial independence in these sensitive courts.

Q: I am a government contract employee with a fixed-term contract. Does this ruling help me? A: The principle helps, yes: a subsequent change in service rules cannot silently erase a tenure already granted. If the government tries to end your fixed term early on the basis of a new rule, ask what statutory provision authorises ending existing appointments — a general new rule, without transitional provisions covering current appointees, is vulnerable to exactly the challenge that succeeded here. That said, every case turns on its own appointment letter and governing statute, so get legal advice on your specific documents rather than relying on this judgment alone.

Q: Why did the judges lose before the SHC Circuit Court but win in the FCC? A: They first challenged their removal before the Sindh High Court Circuit Court's division bench at Hyderabad, which ruled against them. They then took the matter to the Federal Constitutional Court, which disagreed with the Circuit Court's reading of the 2025 amendment — holding that the age limit could not be stretched to cover existing fixed-term appointments without express statutory language — and set the Circuit Court's order aside. Appellate and constitutional courts exist precisely to correct such errors of legal interpretation.

The Bottom Line

This article provides general legal information for readers in Pakistan and is not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.