On 2 November 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) of Pakistan gave an answer to a question that goes to the heart of how the country's court system now works: is the FCC bound by the judgments of the Supreme Court?

The court's answer was clear. It ruled that it is not bound by judgments of the Supreme Court. Such decisions carry persuasive weight rather than binding authority in proceedings before the constitutional court. The FCC said it may seek guidance from Supreme Court decisions and adopt their principles where they agree with the Constitution and applicable laws — but those decisions do not bind it.

This article explains, in plain language, what that ruling means, why it matters, and what it does — and does not — change for ordinary litigants. It also explains the related points the court made about review petitions and about leave to appeal, because those points affect how cases reach and move through the courts.

The case in which the ruling was given

The ruling came while the FCC was dismissing a review petition filed by Balochistan Trading Company, which sought restoration of a lease and possession of property. The court dismissed the review petition and also ordered forfeiture of the security deposit lodged with the petition.

It is important to keep the two parts of the decision separate in your mind:

  • The main point of law: The FCC is not bound by Supreme Court judgments; those judgments are persuasive, not binding, before the FCC.
  • The result in this particular case: The review petition was dismissed, the lease and possession were not restored through this petition, and the security deposit was forfeited.

The ruling on binding precedent is a general statement of law that will be relevant to future cases before the FCC. The dismissal and forfeiture are the outcome for this particular petitioner. Neither part should be confused with the other.

Binding vs persuasive precedent: the basic idea

To understand the ruling, you first need to understand precedent — the idea that courts follow earlier decisions.

In a system based on precedent, earlier decisions of higher courts guide later cases. But not every earlier decision has the same force. Lawyers draw a key distinction:

  • Binding precedent: A decision that a court MUST follow, even if the judges in the later case might have decided the point differently on their own. Binding precedent usually comes from a court higher in the same hierarchy, or from the same court in certain circumstances. A lower court cannot simply disagree with a binding decision of a higher court; it must apply it.
  • Persuasive precedent: A decision that a court MAY consider and follow if it finds the reasoning convincing, but is not obliged to follow. Persuasive authority is respected and taken seriously, but the court remains free to reach a different conclusion if it believes the Constitution or the law points another way.

A helpful everyday comparison: a binding precedent is like a rule you must obey, while a persuasive precedent is like strong advice from a very experienced person — you would be unwise to ignore it without good reason, but you are not legally forced to follow it.

Before the FCC ruling, many readers would have assumed that Supreme Court judgments bind every court in Pakistan. That assumption was understandable, because the Supreme Court has historically sat at the top of the judicial system and its decisions have guided the whole judiciary. The FCC's ruling says that, for proceedings before the FCC itself, that assumption no longer holds in the same way: Supreme Court decisions are guidance the FCC may adopt, not commands it must obey.

Why the FCC's position matters after the 26th and 27th amendments

The FCC is a new institution in Pakistan's judicial structure, created through the recent constitutional amendments — the 26th and 27th amendments — which reshaped the constitutional jurisdiction of the courts. Understanding the ruling requires understanding why a new constitutional court changes the old picture.

Under the previous arrangement, the Supreme Court was the final court for constitutional questions as well as for other appeals. Its judgments therefore naturally set the direction for the entire system, and lower courts were bound to follow them.

The creation of a separate Federal Constitutional Court changed that structure. Constitutional cases of the kind now assigned to the FCC are decided by the FCC, not by the Supreme Court. The FCC is therefore not a "lower court" sitting underneath the Supreme Court in the old sense; it is a distinct constitutional court with its own jurisdiction. The 2 November ruling follows logically from that new structure: if the FCC is the court entrusted with deciding constitutional questions, it cannot be bound, in its own constitutional proceedings, by the decisions of a different court, even one as senior as the Supreme Court.

That does not mean Supreme Court judgments have become irrelevant. Far from it. The FCC itself said it may seek guidance from Supreme Court decisions and adopt their principles where they agree with the Constitution and applicable laws. In practice, that means:

  • Supreme Court reasoning will still be cited, studied and argued before the FCC in almost every major constitutional case.
  • Where the FCC agrees with a Supreme Court principle, it can adopt it — and once adopted by the FCC in its own judgment, that principle becomes part of the FCC's own jurisprudence.
  • Where the FCC disagrees, or where it finds that a Supreme Court principle does not sit well with the Constitution as it now stands, it is free to depart from it, giving reasons.

For lawyers, this changes how arguments are framed. It is no longer enough to say, "The Supreme Court has already decided this, so the FCC must follow." Counsel will now need to persuade the FCC on the merits: that the earlier reasoning is correct, that it agrees with the Constitution and the applicable law, and that it should be adopted. For judges of the FCC, it places a heavier responsibility on their own reasoning, because they cannot simply rest on an earlier Supreme Court decision as a binding answer.

What review petitions can and cannot do

The FCC's ruling also stressed that its review power is narrow. This is a point that confuses many litigants, so it is worth explaining carefully.

After a court gives a final judgment, a losing party sometimes files a review petition, asking the same court to look at its own decision again. It is natural to think of review as a second chance — a fresh hearing, or a chance to re-argue the whole case. In law, it is nothing of the sort.

Review is a limited, exceptional remedy. In general terms:

  • What review can do: It can correct an error that is apparent on the face of the record, or address a specific, narrow ground recognised by law for review — for example, where something material was overlooked that goes to the face of the judgment itself.
  • What review cannot do: It cannot reopen a case, grant a fresh hearing on issues already decided, or give the losing party a second opportunity to argue the same points in the hope of a different result. It is not an appeal in disguise, and it is not a rehearing.

The FCC's statement in this case fits that established understanding: its review power is narrow, it cannot reopen a case, and it cannot grant a fresh hearing on issues already decided. That is why the Balochistan Trading Company's review petition — which sought restoration of a lease and possession of property — was dismissed rather than treated as a new hearing of the underlying dispute.

This point has a recent and striking illustration. The task of explaining this ruling also requires noting the recent dismissal of 1,178 review petitions against the income support levy ruling. That large-scale dismissal is consistent with the narrow view of review: a large number of petitions, however sincerely filed, cannot succeed if they amount in substance to asking the court to reopen decided issues rather than pointing to a reviewable error. The figure itself tells a story about expectations: many litigants appear to treat review as another appeal, and the courts repeatedly have to explain that it is not.

For an ordinary litigant, the practical lesson is blunt but important: do not count on review to fix a lost case. The time to make your full argument is at the original hearing and, where available, on appeal. Review is a safety valve for a narrow class of errors, not a second innings.

The forfeiture of the security deposit in the Balochistan Trading Company case is a further reminder that litigation has costs and consequences. A security deposit lodged with a petition is not a formality; it can be lost if the petition fails. Litigants should understand, before filing, what sums are at stake beyond lawyers' fees.

How leave to appeal works

The FCC also clarified the law on appeals, referring to Article 175F(1)(c) of the Constitution. This part of the ruling matters to anyone thinking of challenging a High Court judgment in a case that falls within the FCC's domain. The court's points, in plain language, are:

  • Leave must be obtained first: Before a relevant High Court judgment can be challenged before the constitutional court, leave to appeal must be obtained from the constitutional court. You cannot simply file an appeal as of right and expect it to be heard.
  • Leave is not automatic: The grant of leave is a decision in itself. The court examines whether the case is fit for appeal — for example, whether it raises a substantial question of law or a matter of sufficient importance — and it may refuse leave.
  • An application becomes an appeal only once leave is granted: Until leave is granted, what you have filed is an application for leave, not an appeal. The distinction matters for procedure, for timelines, and for what the court is actually deciding at each stage.
  • Refusing leave does not endorse the High Court judgment: This is a point the court specifically stressed, and it is easily misunderstood. If the FCC refuses leave, it is not saying the High Court was right. It is saying that the case is not one it will hear on appeal. The High Court judgment stands, because it has not been overturned — but it has not received the FCC's stamp of approval either. A refusal of leave should not be quoted later as if the FCC had agreed with the High Court's reasoning.

Put together, the leave system acts as a filter. It allows the constitutional court to concentrate on cases that raise genuine constitutional or legal questions of significance, rather than rehearing every High Court decision. For litigants, it means the first battle is often the leave application itself: you must show why your case deserves to be heard, before you get to argue the full merits of the appeal.

What this means for ordinary litigants

The ruling may sound technical, but its message for ordinary people is straightforward and, in some ways, reassuring. Your case before the FCC will be decided on the Constitution and the law, not automatically on old Supreme Court rulings.

That has several practical consequences:

  • Your argument must stand on its own merits: Citing a Supreme Court judgment helps, but it is not the end of the argument. You — or your lawyer — will need to show why that judgment's reasoning is right, and why it agrees with the Constitution and the applicable law as they stand today.
  • Old answers can be revisited: If a Supreme Court decision was given under a different constitutional arrangement, or if its reasoning does not fit the Constitution as it now stands, the FCC is free to say so. That is a significant change from a system in which the older decision would have bound every court.
  • Expect longer, more reasoned arguments: Because the FCC must decide for itself rather than simply following a binding precedent, its judgments may engage more deeply with constitutional text, principles and competing arguments. For readers of judgments, that means FCC decisions are worth reading in full, not just for their conclusions but for their reasoning.
  • Do not treat review as a fallback plan: If you lose, review will only help in the narrow circumstances described above. Plan your case on the basis that the original hearing — and, where leave is granted, the appeal — is where it will be won or lost.
  • Understand the leave stage: If you wish to challenge a High Court judgment, the first hurdle is obtaining leave. A refusal of leave ends that route, but it does not mean the FCC agreed with the High Court. If leave is granted, only then does the full appeal begin.
  • Costs and deposits are real: As the forfeiture in this case shows, filing petitions can carry financial consequences. Take advice on costs, deposits and risks before filing, not after.

None of this means that the law has become uncertain or that past judgments have been discarded. Stability still matters enormously in law, and courts value consistency. A persuasive precedent from the Supreme Court will still carry great weight in practice, because it comes from the country's most senior judges and often reflects careful, considered reasoning. The change is about who has the final say in constitutional proceedings before the FCC — and the FCC has now said, plainly, that the final say is its own, guided by the Constitution and the law.

A neutral note on the ruling's significance

This ruling is best read as a structural statement, not a political one. It defines the relationship between two courts in a reorganised judicial system. It does not decide any political dispute, and it does not, by itself, change the outcome of any particular case except by setting the rules under which future cases will be argued.

Legal systems change when their structures change, and the creation of the FCC is such a structural change. The 2 November ruling is the FCC's way of explaining, at an early stage of its work, how it understands its own place in that structure: independent in its constitutional jurisdiction, respectful of Supreme Court jurisprudence, but not bound by it.

For lawyers, students and interested citizens, the ruling is therefore worth studying closely — not only for the headline that Supreme Court judgments are persuasive rather than binding before the FCC, but for the connected guidance on review and leave to appeal, which together describe how cases actually move through the constitutional court.

What to watch next

Several things are worth watching as this ruling is applied in practice:

  • How the FCC treats Supreme Court precedent in future cases: Will it adopt most Supreme Court principles, depart from them rarely, or develop a distinctive body of reasoning of its own? The pattern will emerge case by case.
  • How lawyers adapt their arguments: Expect written submissions before the FCC to argue Supreme Court authorities on their merits, with closer attention to constitutional text, rather than relying on binding force alone.
  • How the leave filter operates: The volume and success rate of leave applications will show how open or restrictive the FCC's appellate gateway is in practice.
  • Whether review filings change: If litigants absorb the message that review is narrow, the number of speculative review petitions may fall — though the recent dismissal of 1,178 review petitions suggests that message still needs repeating.

The FCC has spoken clearly on its own authority. What remains is to see how that authority is exercised, one judgment at a time.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. If you have a case before any court, consult a qualified lawyer about your specific situation.