Picture this: a mother in Lahore holds a court order that says her two young children will stay with her, and their father will pay Rs35,000 every month for each child. The father is not satisfied. He goes to a higher court, hoping it will hand the children to him and cut the money further. Then he goes higher still — to the Lahore High Court itself — asking it to overturn everything. On 20 October 2026, the Lahore High Court gave its answer: no. The children stay with their mother. The maintenance stays at Rs35,000 a month per child.
This ruling, in the case of Kashif Mehmood versus Sadia Fida and others (Writ Petition No. 49905/2026), decided by Justice Shireen Imran of the Lahore High Court, touches the two questions that come up most often in broken marriages in Pakistan: who keeps the children, and who pays for them. Whether you are a mother fighting to keep your children, a father who genuinely believes he should have custody, or a parent arguing over maintenance, this judgment speaks to you. This article explains it in plain language — what the courts decided at each stage, why the High Court refused to interfere, and what it means for your own case.
The Case in Brief
Kashif Mehmood, the father, filed a petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act 1890 — the law under which a person claiming to be a child's guardian can ask the court to be given custody. He asked for custody of his two minor children. At the same time, he asked the court to reduce the maintenance he had been ordered to pay.
This combination — custody plus a maintenance reduction — is extremely common. When a marriage breaks down, the father often petitions for custody, and parallel proceedings fix how much he must pay for the children's upkeep. The two tracks ran side by side here, and the father lost on both.
How the Case Travelled Through Three Courts
Round 1: The Family Court
The family court decided two things. First, it gave custody of the minors to the mother, while giving the father a visitation schedule — regular, fixed contact with his children, so that the relationship between father and children continues even though they live with their mother. Second, it fixed maintenance at Rs50,000 per month per child, with a 10% annual increase, and also ordered the father to pay Rs25,000 per month as iddat maintenance to the mother.
Let us pause on those numbers, because they matter. Rs50,000 per month per child means Rs100,000 a month for two children, rising by 10% every year. The 10% annual increase is a standard feature of modern maintenance decrees — it recognises that school fees, food, clothing and medical costs rise every year, and that a fixed figure set today would lose value over time. Iddat maintenance — maintenance paid to a divorced wife during her iddat period — is a separate, well-established head of maintenance under Muslim family law.
Round 2: The Appellate Court
The father appealed to the Additional District & Sessions Judge, the court that hears appeals from family courts. That court took a second look at the money and reduced maintenance from Rs50,000 to Rs35,000 per month per child. It upheld everything else: custody stayed with the mother, the visitation schedule stayed, and the iddat maintenance stood.
This is how the appeal system is supposed to work. The appellate court reviewed the evidence — the children's needs, the father's means, the cost of living — and made its own assessment of the right figure. A reduction on appeal is not unusual; it reflects the appellate court's independent judgment on the facts.
Round 3: The Lahore High Court
Still unhappy, the father filed a constitutional petition in the Lahore High Court. And this is where the case ended. Justice Shireen Imran dismissed the petition. The children stay with their mother. The maintenance stays at Rs35,000 per month per child.
The Big Principle: The Child's Welfare Comes First
The heart of this ruling is a principle that every custody case in Pakistan turns on: the welfare of the minor is the paramount consideration. Under the Guardians and Wards Act 1890 (Section 17), when a court decides who should have custody, it must consider the welfare of the child above everything else — above the father's claim, above the mother's claim, above family tradition.
A father often argues that he has a preferential right to custody — that as the father, the children naturally belong with him, especially as they grow older. Pakistani courts have heard this argument thousands of times. Their consistent answer is that no such right is absolute. Whatever legal or customary preference a parent may claim yields to the welfare of the child. The question is never "who has the better claim as a parent?" but "where will these children be better off?"
In this case, the lower courts had done something important: they had interviewed the children themselves. Judges in custody cases often speak to older minors privately — in chambers, away from both parents — to understand their feelings. Here, the children expressed the wish to stay with their mother. That is not a trivial detail. When minors of an age to express a preference say clearly where they want to live, courts give that real weight. It was one of the facts the appellate court relied on, and the High Court accepted it.
Why the Father's Writ Petition Failed: A Constitutional Petition Is Not a Retrial
This is the point that confuses many litigants. The father had already been heard twice — by the family court and by the appellate court. When he filed a constitutional petition (a writ petition under Article 199 of the Constitution) in the Lahore High Court, he was essentially asking for a third hearing of the same dispute.
But a constitutional petition is not an appeal, and not a retrial. The High Court in writ jurisdiction does not re-weigh the evidence, re-interview the children, or substitute its own view of the right maintenance figure. It asks a much narrower set of questions:
- Did the lower courts act without jurisdiction (decide something they had no power to decide)?
- Did they commit an error of law (apply the wrong legal principle)?
- Did they act arbitrarily or perversely (reach a conclusion no reasonable court could reach)?
If the answer to all three is no — if the family court and the appellate court followed the law, heard both sides, and reached reasonable conclusions — the High Court will decline to interfere, even if a different judge might have fixed a slightly different maintenance figure. That is exactly what happened here. The High Court found no legal or jurisdictional error in how custody and maintenance had been decided, so it dismissed the petition and left both standing.
The practical lesson is sharp: a writ petition cannot be used as a second appeal. Litigants who lose in the family court and then in the appellate court cannot simply carry the same factual arguments to the High Court under a new label. Unless the lower courts got the law wrong, the writ will fail — and the litigant will have spent more money and more months to arrive at the same answer.
Maintenance: What a Father Must Pay — And Cannot Easily Dodge
The second half of the case concerns maintenance, and here the ruling carries a clear message: a father's duty to maintain his children does not disappear because he finds the amount uncomfortable.
Under Pakistani law, a father is bound to maintain his minor children. The family court fixes the amount based on the children's reasonable needs (food, clothing, housing, education, medical care) and the father's means (income and financial capacity). When a father pleads financial difficulty, the court listens — the appellate court here did reduce the figure from Rs50,000 to Rs35,000 per child, which shows courts do adjust where the evidence supports it. But a general plea of "I cannot afford it," without proof, does not erase the duty.
Note the path the reduction took: it happened on appeal, on the facts — the appellate judge reviewed the evidence and fixed a new figure. It did not happen on writ, where the High Court refused to reopen the numbers at all. For fathers, this is the crucial distinction: if you believe the maintenance figure is wrong, your remedy is a proper appeal with proper evidence of your income and the children's actual needs. A constitutional petition is not a shortcut to a lower number.
Also note what the High Court left untouched: the iddat maintenance of Rs25,000 per month to the mother. Iddat maintenance is the divorced wife's entitlement during her waiting period, and its survival through all three rounds of litigation confirms that it stands on its own legal footing, independent of the custody and child-maintenance fight.
For Mothers: Getting the Maintenance Decree Actually Enforced
A maintenance order is only as good as its enforcement, and this is where many custodial mothers struggle. The father in this case is now bound to pay Rs35,000 per month per child — but what if he simply does not pay?
Pakistani family courts have real enforcement teeth, and mothers should know about them:
- Execution petition: If the father defaults, the mother can file an execution application before the family court that passed the decree, asking it to recover the arrears.
- Attachment of salary and assets: The executing court can order attachment of the father's salary (deducted at source by his employer), bank accounts, and movable or immovable property to satisfy the arrears.
- Detention in civil prison: Persistent, wilful default can lead to the father being detained — courts use this as a last-resort pressure to compel payment.
- Keep a written record: Every payment received and missed should be documented — bank transfer records, receipts, or at minimum a dated diary. When you go back to court for enforcement, a clean arrears calculation is your strongest weapon.
A further practical point from this case: the 10% annual increase that the family court originally ordered (and which the appellate court did not disturb) means the figure grows each year without the mother having to file a fresh case. If your own decree has no escalation clause, you can apply for enhancement of maintenance as costs rise — you do not have to live forever with a figure fixed years ago.
For Fathers: What to Know Before You Challenge Maintenance
This judgment is also a guide for fathers who believe their maintenance burden is unfair:
- Appeal promptly, with evidence. The one reduction in this case came at the appellate stage. If you want the figure changed, the appeal court is the forum — and it needs proof: salary slips, bank statements, evidence of other liabilities, and evidence of the children's actual expenses. Bare assertions of poverty do not move courts.
- Do not stop paying while you litigate. Courts look very unfavourably on a father who withholds maintenance during proceedings. Arrears pile up, interest in the form of judicial displeasure grows, and enforcement action can begin even while your challenge is pending.
- Custody and maintenance are separate fights. Asking for custody does not suspend the duty to pay maintenance, and losing the custody petition does not reduce what you owe. The father here fought on both fronts and lost on both — but legally, each stands on its own.
- Use the visitation schedule. The court gave this father structured visitation. Fathers who engage sincerely with visitation — showing up on time, every time — protect their long-term position far better than those who treat access as a bargaining chip.
- A writ is not a plan B appeal. As this case demonstrates, taking factual grievances about maintenance to the High Court in a constitutional petition is almost certain to fail. Spend the writ-petition money on a better-prepared appeal instead.
The Numbers in This Case, Simply Put
To keep the figures straight:
| Stage | Custody | Maintenance per child | Other |
|---|---|---|---|
| Family court | Mother (father gets visitation) | Rs50,000/month, +10% yearly | Rs25,000/month iddat maintenance to mother |
| Appellate court (AD&SJ) | Mother (visitation upheld) | Rs35,000/month | Rest upheld |
| Lahore High Court (Justice Shireen Imran) | Mother — writ dismissed | Rs35,000/month — stands | — |
One Important Note About the Source
An honest word about where this account comes from. The facts of this case are reported in Dawn's report of 20 October 2026, as carried and summarised by legal reporting services. The judgment text itself could not be located on the Lahore High Court's online portal at the time of writing, and no PLD or SCMR citation for the ruling exists yet. That is normal for a very recent decision — reported judgments take time to be published — but it means fine details (such as the precise reasoning paragraphs) should be treated as reported rather than verified until the full text is available. If you are a lawyer relying on this case in court, wait for the certified judgment or the law-report citation before citing it as precedent.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: The father wanted custody of his children. Why did the courts keep refusing? A: Because custody in Pakistan is decided by one test above all: the welfare of the minor. A father's claim to custody — sometimes called his preferential right — is not absolute; it yields to what is best for the children. Here, the lower courts interviewed the children, who said they wanted to stay with their mother, and found their welfare lay with her. The father was given a visitation schedule so he keeps regular contact. The Lahore High Court found no legal error in that approach and refused to interfere.
Q: Can the High Court change a maintenance figure fixed by the family court? A: In a constitutional (writ) petition, effectively no — not on the facts. The High Court in writ jurisdiction only interferes for errors of law or jurisdiction; it does not re-decide what the right monthly figure should be. That is the appellate court's job. In this case the Additional District & Sessions Judge did reduce maintenance from Rs50,000 to Rs35,000 per child on appeal — the proper forum for that argument. The High Court then declined to touch the figure again.
Q: My ex-husband says he cannot afford the maintenance the court ordered. Does that end his duty? A: No. A father's duty to maintain his minor children does not end with a plea of financial difficulty. Courts fix maintenance by balancing the children's reasonable needs against the father's proven means. If his circumstances genuinely change, he can seek a reduction through a proper appeal or review with documentary evidence of his income — but a bare claim of hardship, and certainly a writ petition re-arguing the same facts, will not succeed.
Q: What is iddat maintenance, and why did the mother get Rs25,000 a month? A: Iddat maintenance is the maintenance a divorced wife is entitled to during her iddat — the waiting period after divorce prescribed by Islamic law. It is separate from child maintenance. In this case the family court awarded Rs25,000 per month as iddat maintenance, and that award survived the appeal and the High Court petition untouched.
Q: The father got a visitation schedule. What does that actually mean? A: It means the court fixed specific days, times and conditions on which the father may meet and spend time with his children, even though they live with their mother. Visitation schedules are enforceable court orders — the custodial parent must honour them, and the visiting parent must stick to them. Fathers should treat every visit seriously: consistent, reliable contact protects the parent-child bond and the father's standing in any future proceedings.
Q: My husband is not paying the maintenance the court ordered. What can I do? A: File an execution application in the family court that passed the decree. The executing court can attach his salary, bank accounts and property to recover arrears, and in cases of wilful default can order his detention. Keep a careful written record of every missed payment with dates and amounts — a clean arrears statement makes enforcement faster. If costs have risen since the decree, you can also apply for enhancement of maintenance.
Q: Can I file a writ petition in the High Court if I lose my family court appeal? A: You can file one, but as this case shows, it will almost certainly fail if your complaint is really about the facts — the custody decision, the maintenance figure, the evidence. A constitutional petition is not a second appeal. The High Court will only interfere if the lower courts acted without jurisdiction or made an error of law. Before spending money on a writ, ask your lawyer a blunt question: "What error of law are we alleging?" If there is no clear answer, the writ is not the right remedy.
The Bottom Line
This article provides general legal information for readers in Pakistan and is not legal advice. For advice about your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.
