In a significant ruling on the division of judicial power under Pakistan's amended Constitution, the Supreme Court has held that it no longer has jurisdiction to hear cases filed under the National Accountability Bureau law, and that such matters now fall within the jurisdiction of the Federal Constitutional Court. The decision, pronounced by a three-member bench and reported in early November 2026, redirects NAB appeals and bail petitions to the Federal Constitutional Court and has immediate consequences for pending cases — including a bail petition filed by Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf founder Imran Khan.

The ruling is not about whether any particular accused person is guilty or innocent. It is about which court is entitled to hear the case at all. Jurisdiction questions of this kind sound technical, but they decide everything practical: where a petition must be filed, which court's orders bind the trial court, and whether months of proceedings in one court have to start again in another. For anyone facing a NAB reference, or waiting on a NAB appeal or bail matter, this ruling changes the map.

What the Supreme Court decided

A three-member bench headed by Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar, with Justice Musarrat Hilali and Justice Shahid Bilal Hassan, pronounced the reserved verdict. Justice Mazhar authored the 30-page judgment, and Justice Hilali wrote an additional note. The bench had reserved its verdict on 16 July 2026 on the question whether the Supreme Court retains jurisdiction over bail applications in pending NAB cases, or whether such pleas must be transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court under the Constitution.

The Court's answer was clear. Sections 32 and 32A of the NAB law do not confer jurisdiction on the Supreme Court to hear such matters. All NAB-related cases are to be treated as transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court under Articles 175A and 175F of the Constitution. The Federal Constitutional Court will hear principal appeals and bail petitions in NAB cases.

The practical effect was illustrated immediately. Imran Khan had approached the Supreme Court after challenging a High Court decision in his bail case, but the Supreme Court registrar had returned the petition after raising objections. Under the ruling, that bail matter, like other NAB bail petitions, belongs before the Federal Constitutional Court rather than the Supreme Court.

Why the jurisdiction moved: the 26th and 27th Amendments and the NAB Amendment Act 2026

To understand the ruling, it helps to understand what changed in the constitutional structure. The 26th Constitutional Amendment created the Federal Constitutional Court as a separate constitutional court, and the 27th Amendment further reshaped the judicial landscape. Under Articles 175A and 175F, as amended, constitutional matters of certain kinds — including, on the Court's reading, appeals and petitions arising under the NAB law — now fall within the Federal Constitutional Court's domain.

The statutory side of the change came through the National Accountability (Amendment) Act, 2026. On 5 March 2026, Section 32-A was inserted into the NAB law, providing for a second appeal: any person convicted, or the Prosecutor General Accountability if so directed by the Chairman NAB, who is aggrieved by a decision of the High Court under Section 32, may prefer a second appeal to the Federal Constitutional Court within 30 days.

The Attorney General for Pakistan argued before the Supreme Court that, under the NAB Amendment Act 2026, all appeals and bail applications against the decisions of the High Courts in NAB cases stand transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court. The Supreme Court accepted that position. The combined effect of the constitutional amendments and the statutory amendment is that the appellate ladder in NAB cases now runs from the accountability court to the High Court, and from the High Court to the Federal Constitutional Court — not to the Supreme Court.

What "transferred" means for pending cases

The judgment states that all NAB-related cases are to be treated as transferred to the Federal Constitutional Court. That word matters. A transfer is not a dismissal. It does not mean that pending appeals and bail petitions die, or that accused persons must start from scratch. It means the file moves to the court that now has the authority to decide it.

For litigants, however, a transfer still has practical consequences. A petition filed in the Supreme Court that is now within the Federal Constitutional Court's jurisdiction will need to be pursued there. Lawyers will need to check whether a fresh filing, a transferred file, or an application for transfer is required in each pending matter, and limitation periods — including the 30-day period for a second appeal under Section 32-A — must be watched carefully. An accused person who assumes that a petition pending in the Supreme Court will simply be decided there risks finding that the forum has changed beneath them.

For bail petitions, the stakes are higher still. Bail is time-sensitive: every week of delay is a week in custody. The ruling clarifies that NAB bail petitions belong before the Federal Constitutional Court, so counsel for detained accused persons should move promptly to place their matters before the correct court rather than waiting for the Supreme Court to act on a petition it has now held it cannot hear.

What the ruling does not decide

It is important not to over-read the judgment. The Supreme Court did not acquit anyone, did not quash any NAB reference, and did not declare the NAB law itself unconstitutional. It decided a question of forum: which apex court hears NAB matters after the constitutional amendments. The merits of individual references, the legality of individual arrests, and the correctness of individual convictions remain to be decided by the courts that now have jurisdiction over them.

The ruling also does not mean the Supreme Court has lost all relevance to accountability matters. It means that the specific appellate and bail jurisdiction under Sections 32 and 32A of the NAB law now vests in the Federal Constitutional Court. Other questions — for example, a constitutional challenge to a law itself, or a matter that falls within the Supreme Court's remaining jurisdiction — will still be governed by the constitutional text and by future rulings drawing the boundary between the two apex courts.

That boundary is itself still being drawn. Only days before this ruling, the Federal Constitutional Court held, on 2 November 2026, that Supreme Court judgments are persuasive rather than binding on it. The two apex courts are now defining their relationship case by case, and lawyers and litigants should expect further rulings clarifying which court decides what.

What this means for an accused person in a NAB case

If you or a family member faces a NAB reference, the ruling has several practical implications.

First, check where your appeal or bail petition is pending. If it is before the Supreme Court under the NAB law, ask your lawyer whether it now needs to be moved to the Federal Constitutional Court, and whether any fresh filing or transfer application is needed. Do not assume the transfer happens automatically in every case.

Second, watch limitation. The 30-day period for a second appeal under Section 32-A runs from the High Court's decision. Missing it can be fatal to the appeal, and the fact that the forum has changed is not, by itself, a guarantee that delay will be condoned.

Third, understand the hierarchy. The accountability court tries the reference. The High Court hears the first appeal under Section 32. The Federal Constitutional Court now hears the second appeal under Section 32-A, as well as bail petitions in NAB cases. Filing in the wrong court at any stage costs time, and in bail matters, time in custody.

Fourth, keep expectations realistic. A change of forum does not change the evidence, the charges, or the law that applies to the merits. It changes who decides. The strength of a bail petition still depends on the merits — the nature of the charge, the stage of trial, the accused's role, and the record — not on which apex court hears it.

What this means for the accountability system

Beyond individual cases, the ruling is part of a larger restructuring of Pakistan's superior judiciary. The creation of the Federal Constitutional Court, and the transfer of NAB appellate jurisdiction to it, concentrates constitutional and certain appellate work in a dedicated court. Supporters of the change argue that it gives constitutional questions a specialised forum and relieves the Supreme Court's docket. Critics worry about fragmentation — two apex courts, with overlapping questions about which one decides what, and the risk that litigants will be bounced between forums while their cases stall.

Both concerns point in the same practical direction: the boundary between the two courts will be tested repeatedly, and each ruling that draws it — like this one — matters for the next case. For now, the clear rule for NAB litigants is that appeals and bail petitions under the NAB law go to the Federal Constitutional Court. Lawyers filing NAB matters should file there, and clients should ask their counsel to confirm the forum before any filing is made.

A note on the Imran Khan bail petition

Because the ruling touches a bail petition filed by Imran Khan, it will inevitably be read politically. But its legal content is jurisdictional, not personal. The Supreme Court registrar had already returned the petition after raising objections, and the ruling explains why the Supreme Court is not the forum for it. The merits of that bail plea — whether bail should be granted on the facts of the case — will now be for the Federal Constitutional Court to consider, if and when the matter is properly placed before it. Treating a jurisdiction ruling as a decision on the merits of any individual's case would be a mistake, and it would mislead readers about what the courts have actually decided.

Questions every NAB litigant should ask their lawyer this week

The transfer of jurisdiction creates a short checklist that any person with a pending NAB matter should work through with counsel. First, is my matter a "NAB case" within the ruling — an appeal under Section 32, a second appeal under Section 32-A, or a bail petition in a NAB reference? If so, it belongs before the Federal Constitutional Court. Second, has anything already been filed in the Supreme Court, and if so, does it need to be withdrawn, transferred, or refiled? Third, what is the limitation position — has the 30-day period for a second appeal already started, and is there any time left? Fourth, if the matter is a bail petition for a person in custody, has an urgent application been made before the correct court, so that the change of forum does not add weeks of delay to a person's detention? Fifth, does the case involve any question that might still fall within the Supreme Court's jurisdiction — for instance, a challenge to the vires of a law — so that a different forum analysis applies to that part of the case?

These questions are not academic. In the weeks after a jurisdiction ruling, the most common error is inertia: a file sits in the wrong court while limitation runs and custody continues. The ruling gives litigants clarity; using that clarity promptly is now the litigant's responsibility, and it is a responsibility best discharged with a lawyer who has read the full 30-page judgment rather than only the headlines about it.

The bottom line

The Supreme Court has ruled that it does not have jurisdiction to hear cases under the NAB law, and that NAB appeals and bail petitions now belong to the Federal Constitutional Court under Articles 175A and 175F of the Constitution and Section 32-A of the NAB law, as amended in 2026. Pending NAB matters are to be treated as transferred. For accused persons, their families and their lawyers, the immediate task is practical: confirm the correct forum, move promptly, and watch limitation. Jurisdiction may sound like a technicality, but in a NAB case it decides which court can set you free on bail, hear your appeal, or finally decide your fate — and getting it wrong costs the one thing a litigant cannot recover: time.

This article is general legal information on Pakistani law as of November 2026 and is not legal advice for any particular case. The facts of every case differ; please consult a qualified lawyer about your own matter.